Professor Jane Goodman-Delahunty of Charles Sturt University Australian Graduate School of Policing, Dr. Anne Cossins of the University of South Wales Faculty of Law, and Kate O’Brien of the Monash University School of Psychology and Psychiatry, have published Enhancing the Credibility of Complainants in Child Sexual Assault Trials: The Effect of Expert Evidence and Judicial Directions, forthcoming in Behavioral Sciences and the Law. Here is the abstract:
This study investigated the knowledge and misconceptions of jury-eligible citizens about children’s reliability as witnesses and responses to child sexual assault (CSA), and examined the influence of expert evidence and judicial directions in challenging common misconceptions. Community volunteers (N = 130) read one of five versions of a simulated jury trial, and completed a pre- and post-trial questionnaire to provide measures of their knowledge of children’s responses to sexual abuse, perceptions of victim credibility, and verdict. Results revealed that endorsement of CSA misconceptions negatively impacted ratings of complainant credibility and verdicts. Judicial directions provided before the child complainant testified enhanced complainant credibility, which in turn predicted guilty verdicts. Comparisons of the effectiveness of two procedural legal mechanisms to manage juror misconceptions and improve knowledge about CSA provide guidance for future researchers investigating ways to increase fairness in cases of CSA.
Tags: Anne Cossins, Assessment of crime victims' credibility, Assessment of witnesses' credibility, Behavioral Sciences and the Law, Criminal evidence information systems, Effect of expert evidence on jurors' assessment of crime victims' credibility, Effect of judicial instructions on jurors' assessment of crime victims' credibility, Empirical methods in legal communication studies, Empirical methods in legal informatics, Jane Goodman-Delahunty, Jurors' assessment of crime victims' credibility, Jurors' knowledge of child sexual abuse, Jurors' knowledge of child sexual assault, Jury research, Kate O'Brien, Legal communication, Legal evidence information systems, Legal expert evidence information systems