Fred R. Shapiro of the Yale Law School Library and Michelle Pearse of the Harvard Law School Library have published The Most-Cited Law Review Articles of All Time, Michigan Law Review, 110, 1483-1520 (2012). Here is the abstract:
This Essay updates two well-known earlier studies (dated 1985 and 1996) by the first coauthor, setting forth lists of the most-cited law review articles. New research tools from the HeinOnline and Web of Science databases now allow lists to be compiled that are more thorough and more accurate than anything previously possible. Tables printed here present the 100 most-cited legal articles of all time, the 100 most-cited articles of the last twenty years, and some additional rankings. Characteristics of the top-ranked publications, authors, and law schools are analyzed as are trends in schools of legal thought. Data from the all-time rankings shed light on contributions to legal scholarship made over a long historical span; the recent-article rankings speak more to the impact of scholarship produced in the current era. The authors discuss alternative tools and metrics for measuring the impact of legal scholarship, running selected articles from the rankings through these tools to serve as points of illustration. The authors then contemplate how these alternative tools and metrics intersect with traditional citation studies and how they might impact legal scholarship in the future.
Tags: Citation of law journal articles, Citation of law review articles, Fred R. Shapiro, Fred Shapiro, Hein Online, Law journal articles, Law review articles, Legal citations, Legal scholarly communication, Legal scholarship, Michelle Pearse, Michigan Law Review, Web of Science